fleet-memory/hindsight-api/tests/test_fact_extraction_analysis.py
Nicolò Boschi 8d731f2e5f
feat: implement hierarchical configuration (system, tenant, bank) (#329)
* feat: implement hierarchical configuration (system, tenant, bank)

* feat: implement hierarchical configuration (system, tenant, bank)

* docs: add instructions for hierarchical config in CLAUDE.md

* feat: add ENABLE_BANK_CONFIG_API flag (disabled by default)

- Add HINDSIGHT_API_ENABLE_BANK_CONFIG_API env var (default: false)
- Return 403 Forbidden from bank config endpoints when disabled
- Update tests to enable the flag
- Update CLAUDE.md documentation

This provides security control over the bank configuration API,
ensuring it's only accessible when explicitly enabled.

* docs: add hierarchical configuration section

* feat(cli): add bank config commands (config, set-config, reset-config)

- Add 'hindsight bank config' to view bank configuration
- Add 'hindsight bank set-config' to update LLM settings per bank
- Add 'hindsight bank reset-config' to reset to defaults
- Implements client API calls to new bank config endpoints

* fix(cli): fix compilation errors in bank config commands

- Fix type signature: use ApiClient instead of api::Client
- Fix confirmation: use ui::prompt_confirmation instead of ui::confirm
- Fix error handling: use anyhow! macro instead of errors::Error
- Fix type conversion: convert HashMap to serde_json::Map for API call

* feat: implement type-safe hierarchical config with bank overrides

Implements a production-ready hierarchical configuration system that prevents
accidentally using global defaults when bank-specific overrides exist.

- Created StaticConfigProxy that wraps HindsightConfig
- get_config() now returns proxy that blocks access to bank-configurable fields
- Raises ConfigFieldAccessError with clear message when accessing configurable fields
- Added _get_raw_config() for internal use only
- Forces developers to use resolve_full_config(bank_id, context) for bank settings

- Added resolve_full_config() method that returns complete HindsightConfig
- Resolves hierarchy: Global (env) → Tenant → Bank
- No caching to support multi-server deployments (always fresh from DB)
- LLM provider pooling handles expensive operations separately

- Updated entire retain pipeline to pass resolved config through call chain
- memory_engine.py: Resolves config at top level where bank_id/context available
- orchestrator.py: Accepts and passes config to fact_extraction
- fact_extraction.py: Uses passed config instead of get_config()
- utils.py: Added optional config param for backward compatibility

- consolidator.py: Uses resolve_full_config() for enable_observations check
- memory_engine.py: Resolves config before triggering consolidation

- Renamed "Memory Bank" to "Bank Configuration" with tabs
- Combined Stats and Operations into "General" tab
- Consolidated Profile and Configuration into "Configuration" tab
- Moved Actions dropdown to page level (outside tabs)

- Created new component for managing bank-specific config
- Displays configurable fields: retain_chunk_size, retain_extraction_mode, etc.
- Edit via dialog with form validation
- Reset to defaults via AlertDialog confirmation
- Shows field IDs in monospace for clarity
- Visual separation with borders and hover effects

- Removed inline edit mode, switched to dialog-based editing
- Separate dialogs for Disposition and Mission editing
- Read-only display with clear edit buttons
- Removed duplicate stats cards and operations

- bank-stats-view.tsx: Overview statistics (memories, links, documents, pending ops)
- bank-operations-view.tsx: Background operations table with filtering

**Problem**: Consolidation always used global enable_observations, ignoring bank overrides
**Root Cause**: consolidator.py called get_config() instead of resolving bank-specific config
**Solution**: Pass resolved config through the entire pipeline

**Problem**: asyncpg returning JSONB as JSON string instead of parsed dict
**Solution**: Explicit JSON parsing in config_resolver.py with type checking

- All 19 API integration tests pass
- All 10 hierarchical config tests pass
- Retain operations work correctly with bank-specific config
- Consolidation respects bank-specific enable_observations setting

- Updated developer/configuration.md with type-safe config access pattern
- Added examples showing correct usage patterns
- Documented ConfigFieldAccessError and resolution methods

- get_config() now returns StaticConfigProxy (blocks configurable field access)
- Code accessing bank-configurable fields must use resolve_full_config()
- Clear migration path with helpful error messages

Fixes hierarchical configuration to be production-ready with proper type safety.

* refactor: remove LLM client pool and simplify config resolver

Since LLM config (provider, model, api_key) is now static and not
bank-configurable, the LLMClientPool is no longer needed.

Changes:
- Remove hindsight_api/llm_client_pool.py (no longer needed)
- Remove memory_engine._get_bank_llm_config() (dead code, never called)
- Simplify config_resolver.py by eliminating duplication between
  resolve_full_config() and get_bank_config()
- get_bank_config() now calls resolve_full_config() and filters results
- Remove outdated "LLM provider pooling" comments from docstrings

All tests pass (10 hierarchical config tests, 19 API integration tests)

* fix: update tests to use _get_raw_config() for configurable fields

Fixed test fixtures that were accessing configurable fields (like
enable_observations) from get_config(), which now raises
ConfigFieldAccessError due to type-safe config access.

Changes:
- test_consolidation.py: Changed enable_observations fixture to use
  _get_raw_config() instead of get_config()
- test_consolidation.py: Updated test_consolidation_returns_disabled_status
  to set bank config instead of mocking get_config()
- test_link_expansion_retrieval.py: Changed fixture to use _get_raw_config()
- test_observations.py: Changed disable_observations fixture to use
  _get_raw_config()
- Regenerated OpenAPI spec and clients

All 39 previously failing tests now pass.

* fix: add missing config parameter to test calls of extract_facts_from_text()

Fixed 45 test failures where tests were calling extract_facts_from_text()
without the new required config parameter.

Changes:
- Added config=_get_raw_config() to all extract_facts_from_text() calls
- Fixed test_main_module.py to patch _get_raw_config instead of get_config
- Updated 6 test files with 37 function call sites

All tests should now pass.

* fix: add missing config parameter to test_skip_podcast_meta_commentary

One more test was missing the config parameter for extract_facts_from_text().
2026-02-12 13:14:57 +01:00

103 lines
3.5 KiB
Python

"""
Test to analyze fact extraction token usage and identify optimization opportunities.
"""
import asyncio
import logging
import time
from datetime import datetime
import pytest
from hindsight_api.config import get_config, clear_config_cache, _get_raw_config
from hindsight_api.engine.llm_wrapper import LLMConfig
from hindsight_api.engine.retain.fact_extraction import extract_facts_from_text
logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO)
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
@pytest.fixture
def llm_config():
"""Create LLM config from environment."""
clear_config_cache()
config = get_config()
return LLMConfig(
provider=config.retain_llm_provider or config.llm_provider,
api_key=config.retain_llm_api_key or config.llm_api_key,
model=config.retain_llm_model or config.llm_model,
base_url=config.retain_llm_base_url or config.llm_base_url,
)
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_fact_extraction_basic_analysis(llm_config):
"""
Test fact extraction and analyze token usage with sample content.
This test helps identify:
1. How many facts are extracted
2. Token usage (input/output ratio)
3. Types of facts being extracted
"""
content = """
Alice is a senior software engineer at TechCorp with 8 years of experience.
She has a Kubernetes certification (CKA) and leads the platform team.
Bob is her colleague who works on the frontend. He's been at the company for 3 years.
They're working on a new microservices migration project together.
The deadline for the first milestone is end of Q2.
Alice prefers to use Go for backend services while Bob advocates for TypeScript.
"""
logger.info(f"Content length: {len(content)} chars (~{len(content) // 4} tokens)")
start_time = time.time()
facts, chunks, usage = await extract_facts_from_text(
text=content,
event_date=datetime.now(),
llm_config=llm_config,
agent_name="test-agent",
context="Friday Standup meeting",
config=_get_raw_config(),
)
duration = time.time() - start_time
logger.info(f"\n{'='*60}")
logger.info(f"EXTRACTION RESULTS")
logger.info(f"{'='*60}")
logger.info(f"Duration: {duration:.2f}s")
logger.info(f"Chunks: {len(chunks)}")
logger.info(f"Facts extracted: {len(facts)}")
logger.info(f"Input tokens: {usage.input_tokens}")
logger.info(f"Output tokens: {usage.output_tokens}")
logger.info(f"Token ratio (out/in): {usage.output_tokens / max(1, usage.input_tokens):.2f}")
# Analyze facts by type
fact_types = {}
for fact in facts:
ft = fact.fact_type
fact_types[ft] = fact_types.get(ft, 0) + 1
logger.info(f"\nFacts by type:")
for ft, count in sorted(fact_types.items()):
logger.info(f" {ft}: {count}")
# Show sample facts
logger.info(f"\nSample facts (first 10):")
for i, fact in enumerate(facts[:10]):
logger.info(f"\n [{i+1}] {fact.fact_type}: {fact.fact[:150]}...")
# Show facts containing key terms
key_terms = ["kubernetes", "k8s", "CKA", "certification", "Alice"]
logger.info(f"\n{'='*60}")
logger.info(f"FACTS CONTAINING KEY TERMS")
logger.info(f"{'='*60}")
for term in key_terms:
matching = [f for f in facts if term.lower() in f.fact.lower()]
logger.info(f"\n'{term}' ({len(matching)} facts):")
for fact in matching[:3]:
logger.info(f" - {fact.fact[:200]}...")
assert len(facts) > 0, "Should extract at least one fact"